A pair of convicted felons who killed a 64-year-old Anza man while stealing marijuana and money tied to his illegal cannabis grow were both convicted Tuesday of first-degree murder and other charges.
Jodi Lynn Miller, 48, of Rancho Cucamonga, and Jesse Robert Thurbush, 43, of Victorville murdered James Cidney Brown in 2019.
After three days of deliberations at the Southwest Justice Center, a Murrieta jury returned with the murder verdict, as well as finding Miller and Thurbush guilty of burglary, false imprisonment and special circumstance allegations of killing in the course of a burglary and killing during the commission of a robbery.
Jurors were unable to reach a unanimous decision, however, on whether Miller was additionally guilty of sentence-enhancing gun and great bodily injury allegations.
Riverside County Superior Court Judge Stephen Gallon scheduled a sentencing hearing for Miller on June 7 and Thurbush on July 26.
The defendants are each being held without bail — her at the Smith Correctional Facility in Banning, him at the Byrd Detention Center in Murrieta.
Their co-defendant, James Max Robinson, 43, of San Bernardino, reached a plea deal with the District Attorney’s Office at the outset of the trial, admitting voluntary manslaughter. In exchange for the admission, prosecutors dropped murder and other charges against him.
He’s being held without bail at the Smith jail and is due for sentencing on June 14.
According to a brief filed by Robinson’s attorney last year, when he tried unsuccessfully to have some of the charges against his client dismissed, Miller was the alleged ringleader, and she invited Robinson and Thurbush to her Rancho Cucamonga home on the night of Nov. 2, 2019, to smoke methamphetamine.
The brief, based on evidence presented during the trio’s 2022 preliminary hearing, said Miller wanted to steal marijuana and money from Brown, about whom she’d received information from a friend, James McCance, who tended to the illicit outdoor cannabis grow at the victim’s property in the 39000 block of El Toro Road.
Miller got a layout of the property from McCance. She persuaded Robinson and Thurbursh to join her in the robbery, and the threesome set off in the predawn hours of Nov. 3, 2019, court papers said.
They arrived just before 6 a.m., cutting through a fence to gain access, then parking outside the victim’s house, where Miller armed herself with a revolver, and the two men armed themselves with rifles, with Robinson remaining outside to watch for law enforcement.
Miller and Thurbush slipped into the home through an unlocked backdoor and found a worker, John Fuggiero, asleep on a front room sofa and Brown asleep in his room with the door shut, the brief said.
The defendants subdued Fuggiero with zip ties and sprayed him in the face with pepper spray, then proceeded into Brown’s room, where Robinson discharged spray into the victim’s closed eyes, causing him to wake in a panic, bolting out of the room, according to court documents.
Miller was directly in the fleeing man’s path and fired several shots at him, documents said.
“She was standing there with a gun and … shot Brown because he was running at her,” according to the brief.
Miller and Thurbush ransacked the property for 20 minutes, looking for money and marijuana packages, then fled, along with Robinson, sheriff’s investigators said.
Fuggiero freed himself from the restraints an hour later, calling 911.
Deputies arrived at 7:30 a.m. and found Brown dead in the front room.
Fuggiero was treated for minor injuries.
After Central Homicide Unit detectives searched the grounds, the illegal grow was razed, and all remaining cannabis was seized and destroyed.
The investigation spanned almost 18 months before the three defendants were connected to the murder and arrested in the summer of 2021.
Court records show Miller has a prior felony conviction in another jurisdiction, but it was not specified, while both Robinson and Thurbush each have priors for burglary.
Related Articles
Do you know her? Authorities seek to identify Jane Doe found in Orange County on Ortega Highway in 2006
Man convicted of murder in 2020 shooting of San Jacinto resident following argument
3 men face federal charges tied to theft of $800,000 in stolen checks from post offices
Felon who caused fatal pursuit crash exiting 15 Freeway in Murrieta gets 28 years
Aliso Viejo man was childhood friend of UPS driver he’s accused of shooting to death